• You are here:
  • News & Events
  • News
  • Foreign Policy Experts Share Thoughts on Navigating Crisis
  • Print Page

Foreign Policy Experts Share Thoughts on Navigating Crisis

February 22, 2021

By Jeremy Conrad

      Washington Foreign Law Society Panel

Giuliana Canè, president of the Washington Foreign Law Society, moderates the discussion between Mark Feldman and Jeffrey Smith (clockwise from top left). 

On February 18 the Washington Foreign Law Society hosted part one of its two-part conversation with attorney-diplomats on crisis management, featuring Mark B. Feldman, former deputy and acting legal adviser at the U.S. Department of State, and Jeffrey Smith, former general counsel of the Central Intelligence Agency. 

Feldman reflected on his more than a half-century of legal practice, including 16 years at the State Department, that gave him proximity to, and often involvement in, some of the most historic foreign policy events in recent history — from the Vietnam War to the Iran Hostage Crisis. Interviewed by Smith, Feldman talked about the importance of character and shared a series of anecdotes about his encounters with some of the 20th century’s leading figures in foreign policy.

As a young attorney, Feldman was involved in the drafting of documents that led to the treatment of captured Viet Cong guerillas as prisoners of war entitled to detention conditions subject to the Geneva Conventions. Feldman said he’d been told to “make it right” by William Averell Harriman, whose impact on American foreign policy stretched from the Truman to the Johnson administration. There was significant pushback from the military relating to the policy, though later even detractors would come to appreciate the value in the principled treatment of the enemy, according to Feldman.

Working under Henry Kissinger was an exhilarating experience, Feldman said. At an early meeting, Feldman was bold enough to challenge Kissinger during a debate in which the legal office’s positions were being poorly received. Later, at an event held at the Watergate Hotel, Feldman said he was formally introduced to Kissinger by the latter’s legal advisor, Carlyle Maw. “I know him,” Kissinger said. “He’s the guy that’s giving everybody a rough time.” “That’s what he’s supposed to do,” Maw replied. 

The impression Kissinger made on Feldman remains apparent today. “He had a style that was all his own,” Feldman said. For instance, in negotiations leading to the Helsinki Accords, Feldman recalls Kissinger instructing his aides, “You may attend these meetings, but you will not speak.” An imperious decree, but one that may find justification in that the Accords were successfully concluded, ultimately benefitted the West, emboldened Eastern European states, and contributed to the eventual dissolution of the Soviet Union.

Feldman’s recollections about the Iran Hostage Crisis, by contrast, focused on the difficulties involved in reaching agreement with a party that refuses to negotiate. He said that although the crisis was a political disaster for the Carter administration, the outcome of claims settlement negotiations associated with the crisis was excellent. “The task of the lawyers was to draft an agreement that was sufficiently attractive and plausible for the Iranians that we could conclude a negotiation without ever meeting them. It was quite an amazing undertaking,” Feldman said.

Comparing his years in private practice to his public service, Feldman said that his foreign policy work with the government put him in an environment where he felt comfortable taking principled positions, even when reactions weren’t always positive. 

“I blush to say that in private practice there are a lot of lawyers [who] make a living lying for clients. You don’t need to do that in government,” said Feldman, currently an adjunct professor of law at Georgetown University Law Center. “In my experience, at least, in the State Department, in our generation nobody asked a lawyer to lie for the government. The problem was the clients didn’t want to hear the constraints. No client wants to hear that you can’t do what you want to do.” 

“That’s why Henry Kissinger was yelling at me so often,” Feldman continued. “The risk there is being cut out of decision making and becoming irrelevant in the process, and every legal advisor has to deal with that, but if you’re not prepared to bring your values with you to the job, you might as well do something else.”

Part two of the conversation takes place on March 18, with Feldman interviewing Smith about his involvement in the joint congressional committee investigating the Iran-Contra scandal, spy trades culminating in the release of Soviet dissident Anatoly Sharansky, and his participation as a U.S. observer to the trial of Korean politician Kim Dae Jung, who would later be elected president of the Republic of Korea and receive the Nobel Peace Prize. 

Visit the Washington Foreign Law Society website to register for the next installment of “Inside the Room: Attorney-Diplomats at Work on U.S. Foreign Relations.” The program is cosponsored by the American Society of International Law and the ABA International Law Section.

Recent News

Shaun Snyder

May 05, 2025

Candidates Pitch Vision for the Bar at Member Reception

By Jeremy Conrad

On May 1 D.C. Bar President Shaun Snyder addressed more than 100 members at a reception and lauded many of the Bar’s programs, services, and leadership opportunities, emphasizing the value of relationships he has forged through his involvement with the Bar.

D.C. Superior Court Chief Judge Milton C. Lee Jr.

April 30, 2025

AI and the Courts: Conference Highlights Dangers of New Tech

By Jeremy Conrad

Discussions at the 2025 Judicial & Bar Conference on April 25 reflected on the impact of technological changes on the legal profession, but several panelists also drew attention to the potential harm of artificial intelligence on the orderly administration of justice.

D.C. Superior Court

April 30, 2025

D.C. Courts Release 2024 Capital Pro Bono Honor Roll

Chief Judge Anna Blackburne-Rigsby of the D.C. Court of Appeals and Chief Judge Milton C. Lee, Jr., of the D.C. Superior Court have released the 14th annual Capital Pro Bono Honor Roll, recognizing the contributions of those D.C. Bar members and other lawyers authorized to perform pro bono legal work in the District of Columbia who completed 50 hours or more of pro bono service during the prior calendar year.

Skyline